What begins as an earnest peek into the lives of a group of high-school girls becomes a darker story about sexual misconduct and believing women, through the lens of an interrogation of a classic of the American theater.
Anyone who still remembers their English class homework in high school will likely recognize the name John Proctor. Or, perhaps, if no one ever made you read The Crucible or watch a community theater production of it, you may have seen the 1996 film adaptation starring Daniel Day-Lewis as Proctor and Winona Ryder as Abigail Williams, the teenage girl accused of witchcraft with whom Proctor had an affair.
Famously, Arthur Miller's play was an allegory about the "witch hunts" of the McCarthy Era, and Kimberly Belflower's play John Proctor Is the Villain, which opened Wednesday in its West Coast premiere at ACT following its 2025 run on Broadway, makes a passing reference in its high school English class setting to "everyone talking about witch hunts these days," without ever mentioning Trump by name.
The play is set in a small town in Georgia in 2018, at the height of the #MeToo era, and it will surprise no one to learn that Carter Smith (Kyle Harris), the passionate, handsome English teacher leading the class discussion of The Crucible, and the only adult male in the cast, is a proxy for Proctor, just as he informs his students that Proctor is "one of the great heroes of the American theater."

The play centers on the friendships between five girls, and how they're tested as the father of one of them, Ivy (Stevie Allen), is accused of sexual misconduct (or assault) by one of his employees. Ivy's best friend Beth (Olivia Finkelstein), the teacher's pet and an eager over-achiever, is quick to defend her friend's dad though seems conflicted about what to believe.
Shelby (Lilla Crawford) arrives back at school by surprise after a mysterious absence that is rumored to have something to do with Ivy's dad, and after she has betrayed her childhood best friend Raelynn (Kaylee Kaneshiro) by sleeping with her longtime boyfriend Lee (Mario Houle). And new girl Nell (Varinique Davis), who's recently moved from Atlanta and gladly joins the girls' newly formed Feminism Club, serves as a kind of moral barometer and voice of skepticism throughout.
Without giving too much of the story away, I'll say that the girls all end up standing by each other, and believing each other, even as the adult world around them begins stealing their innocence and betraying their trust. And the play culminates in a triumphant dance sequence set to Lorde's "Green Light" in which the girls are able to take their power and agency back, and protest all the shitty adults who have let them down.
If this all sounds like a crowd-pleasing antidote to toxic masculinity and the gross revelations of the #MeToo era, that is certainly what the playwright seems to be going for. While the play is no doubt effective in its aims and will elicit plenty of snaps and cheers from younger audiences, it can feel a bit ham-fisted at turns, particularly in its parallels with The Crucible and the sometimes didactic tone it takes with fourth-wave feminism and Arthur Miller's strange tone-deafness to his own female characters.
Seen in contrast to Liberation, a play about the feminist movement which just ran on Broadway this past season and is still playing at Berkeley Rep, John Proctor Is the Villain is less nuanced and easier to swallow, wrapping up its themes neatly and refusing to let anyone wallow in their victimhood. As an entry point for young theater-goers, I'd say it's a smashing success, giving a high school English class plenty to hash out the next day. As a play for more sophisticated audiences, I'd say it falls a short of being eye-opening or taking a fresh take on its subject matter, but it's a funny, pleasurable and sometimes moving take nonetheless.
'John Proctor Is the Villain' plays through December 13 at ACT's Toni Rembe Theater. Find tickets here.

Join the conversation
Comments
Comments load automatically as this section approaches.