Last week we asked for your Thanksgiving Dinner Pet Peeves, and among other things, the post promptly started some dispute between pro-Pie and anti-Pie factions. While at least some portion *cough* of SFist editorial staff was against "Warm fruit" in general, one reader even took to the tipline to proclaim very succinctly: "Pie is Disgusting."

Which: fine, you don't like Pie. In general, cake's bread-like utilitarianism seems far less divisive than the many forms of Pie which may be fruit, chocolate, meat or gourd-based. But this leads us to further questioning: Why don't you like pie? Is it the plethora of varieties that offends you? Did you have a bad experience with a savory, meat-smuggling pie? Most importantly, is anyone really "for" Cake?