Every time we see an Errol Morris film, we're always astonished by his subjects' self-incrimination and displays of delusion. We had suspected that Morris is drawn to delusional people as subjects, or at least, the unusually obsessed. With Standard Operating Procedure, screened at the SFIFF on Tuesday, April 29th, Errol Morris once again attempts to answer the question that recurs in many of his movies, "What were they thinking?" In a pre-screening chat with B. Ruby Rich, Morris commented that what he aims to accomplish in his films, is to present how his subjects perceive the world.
Standard Operating Procedure presents the perspectives of several soldiers punished for their roles in the Abu Ghraib torture photo scandal, including Lynndie England (the infamous leash-holder, who had a more flattering haircut in the film), Sabrina Harman (who claims she smiles and makes the thumbs-up gesture in all photos taken of her), but excluding Charles Graner (who most of the interviewees point to as the mastermind of many of the more iconic images, probably evoking jealousy in a number of immature art school students who have since paid homage to his "compositions"). At the end of the film, it was noted that the Military forbade an interview with Graner.
After the jump: Are Donald Rumsfeld and Robert MacNamera morally equivalent?
During the pre-screening Q&A, comparisons were made between Donald Rumsfeld's role in the Iraq debacle and Morris' previous film The Fog of War featuring former Defense Secretary Robert S. MacNamara discussing Vietnam. Morris responded that MacNamara and Rumsfeld were not the same. In Fog of War, MacNamara comes across as self-aware and insightful, whereas we'd imagine Rumsfeld will remain deluded. The interviewees in S.O.P. had moments of both insight and head-shake inducing "wrongness."
The title of the film gains its greatest significance during a sequence late in the film where the infamous photos are presented as a slideshow, and an expert determines whether they depict criminal acts or "standard operating procedure," some of the verdicts being shocking. As this film was on the "hold review" list, revealing which is which would reveal too much



Post a comment (Comment Policy)