About SFist

SFist is a website about San Francisco.

Editor: Brock Keeling
Publisher: Gothamist

About | Advertising | Archive | Contact | Job Board | Mobile | RSS | Staff

Categories
Favorites
Contribute

Latest tip:

Anyone know why Great Highway northbound was shut down at about 6:20 today? Cops put out flares [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Recent Comments
Blogroll
Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from SFist.

November 14, 2007

A Tale of Two Quarterbacks

If there's anybody in the city taking more heat than Mike Nolan, it's his quarterback, Alex Smith. Smith stands accused by the Faithful of not very being good. The evidence? Overthrowing Receivers. Underthrowing Receivers. Not seeing open Receivers. The numbers back up the evidence-- he has a preposterously low QB rating (57.2) and completion percentage (48.7). He is also 11-19 as a starting QB. In the games we've watched, Smith looked like the same QB he was when he first started-- skittish and inaccurate-- so much so, the Faithful are muttering that Smith, as a #1 draft pick, has been a bust of Lucy Pinder-like proportions (sort of NSFW-y).

There are many theories out there for his general awfulness. Is he still hurt? Is the new offensive coordinator lame? Was the brief glimmer of decent play all due to Norv? He also played in a spread offense in college and there's a theory that QBs who play in gimmicky college offenses don't do well in the NFL. And maybe he just isn't a very good QB?

And speaking of #1 draft picks, there is the Raiders. The only reason to care about the Raiders right now is the eventual Coming of JaMarcus. After all, what else do Raiders fans have left to care about? The Raiders are like this season of "Heroes"-- boring and awful with only the possibility of something interesting happening towards the end as the only reason to keep watching-- Save the QB, Save the World. So why isn't the big guy playing? Is he not ready yet? Or maybe it's because whenever Al reappears from his cryogenic freezer, he mandates that the Raiders still need to just win, baby. After all, the AFC West is God-awful and a Raiders' Colorado Rockies-like run can actually send them into the playoffs and that probably won't happen with JaMarcus at the helm. Then again, it probably won't happen with Josh or Daunte and Andrew at the helm either.


Email This Entry







Advertisement: SFist Continues Below!

Comments (1)

I'm not convinced that Alex Smith has all the necessary skills to be a top-flight NFL quarterback: his inability to find the open receiver appears to be the biggest problem. He appears to be a gifted athlete with lots of physical talent, but that alone won't make you a Super Bowl caliber QB; I'm also unsure about his leadership abilities.

By contrast, Joe Montana was never considered to have a strong arm or be nimble. He was a fierce competitor, with an uncanny ability to find the open man, and his poise under pressure makes him one of the greatest clutch quarterbacks in history. Those are innate qualities, things that cannot be gestured in from the coaching staff on the sidelines.

We could debate endlessly about statistics, ratings, etc., but in the end, it's all about wins and losses.

I don't know what the salary cap implications are, but personally, I would think about trading Alex Smith at the end of the season. He's probably a nice guy, but I think a change of scenery would be best for everyone.

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. We use MovableType.