March 16, 2007
March Muni Payout: $57,762.63

At next TuesdayFriday's MTA meeting (March 20, 2pm, Room 400, City Hall), they'll be moving to pay off five claims. Most are unlitigated, so we can't look up the details; the other two are vehicle-property-damage cases that are pretty standard-issue, at least for Muni. One, Evelyn Bravos versus SF, involves a $3,000 fender-bender in the Richmond; the other, San Francisco Food Bank versus SF, involves a bus crash that did about $18,000 in damage.
Muni is not without defense in the Food Bank fiasco: in their answer to the complaint, Muni claimed that the Food Bank knowingly placed itself at risk, so they refused to pay for the damage. But the bus drifted across traffic, up onto the sidewalk, and through the Food Bank's property; so it's not hard to see why, three litigious years later, Muni's finally picking up the tab.
Other beneficiaries: Loretta Culver, who gets $7,000; City Rent-A-Car and Linda King, who get $13,137.35; and Seth Bernstein, who gets $16,400. Happy payday, everyone!
Other business at the meeting involves a consultation with lawyers about the awesome lawsuit that Dan Noyes had KGO file. The news station is trying to find out who those 25 drivers are who racked up a thousand complains in the last three years, but the drivers' union sued to stop Muni from revealing that info. (We've run into that issue ourselves: as a matter of policy, Muni has always refused to disclose the outcome of any customer service complaint. It's like saying, "waiter, there's a fly in my soup," and the waiter goes, "I'll make a note of it.")
Don't expect to learn anything new about that lawsuit at the meeting; when it's time for a-lawyerin', the MTA kicks the public out and holds a closed session. Probably because the lawyers are really timid and shy.


FYI: March 20 = Tuesday
Oops. Thanks.
While looking over other Public Transportation, in particular, MBTA (Boston) it seems that 50K is not that bad on a monthly basis. While exact numbers are hard to come by, it seems that MBTA pays out 1M per month, a significantly larger number than the 50K that MUNI paid this month. Granted, MBTA is servicing a larger area and the legal environment in Mass. is slightly different than the legal environment here, but overall 50K per month for MUNI general liability is not that bad. See Footnote number 10 here .
I looked for some more comparable cities, but was unable to find any specific information -- seems like most people aren't interested in announcing how much money they spend on general liability claims.
That Comes out to $600.000.00 a year. Thats a house.Half a condo.3 new buses.Payroll for 5 or more safe new drivers.16.6 years of pay for me.