
Last night was a meeting about the spate of violent crime and shootings in the Lower Haight. In attendance were various officials from the SFPD, including Heather Fong, as well as supervisors Ross Mirkirami and Bevan Dufty. Dan From Burritophile was in attendance and gives us a report, after the jump. To see photos of the event, click here.
I live in the lower Haight, and had been planning to go to the Tuesday evening community safety meeting at Homilton Square Baptist Church (Oak and Steiner). The meeting was in reaction to the shooting on Haight two weeks ago, but the morning gunfire in broad daylight at the intersection of Haight and Webster turned things a
bit more urgent. The meeting hall was steamy-hot and packed to the gills with angry residents.
Ross Mirkarimi had been on the handbills, but there were two surprise guests: Bevan Dufty and police chief Heather Fong. The atmosphere was tense and pissed; most people were shocked at the morning's violence, upset that nobody seems to ever do anything about the guys who deal crack every day on the 400 block of Haight Street, and determined to do something, anything, to try to head off the latest spate of shooting.
I sat up near the front, near where the KRON and KTVU camera crews were interviewing the organizers. They stayed for about forty minutes, and disappeared - I assume to get back in time to make the ten o'clock newscasts.
The first part of the meeting was essentially set aside for resident venting, and boy did we ever. One weary girl noted that her first Saturday night in the neighborhood after moving from New York had been gunshots and a front-door carjacking. Another guy complained about people buying weed from pot clubs and dealing it openly on the street to people too dumb to pay $300 to the sketchy doctors who advertise in the back of the Guardian. And a woman fought back tears as she talked about how her children walk to school, every morning, crossing the intersection of Haight and Webster. If this morning had gone down ten minutes earlier, those kids would have been in the line of fire.
In true city style, the meeting veered off the agenda after about twenty minutes, when a pointed question about the police department brought Captain Kelly from North Station to the front, where he described what the cops are up to in the Haight, and pointed out that most of what they do we don't see. He was good - calm, focused,
informational. He had an interesting back-and-forth with former supervisor Bill Maher (taking a break from his HBO show), who grilled him about whether cops are actually showing up as witnesses when dealers and thugs are tried, and whether or not the community can help with stay-away orders. Apparently one of the biggest problems is gangbangers coming to our area from other parts of the city, Oakland, and Richmond, and fighting over the corner of Haight and Webster. I don't get the logic behind this, but perhaps that's why I'm a broke freelancer instead of a wealthy crack dealer. Anyway, stay-away orders are supposed to prevent this kind of thing from happening.
Kelly was followed by Chief Heather Fong who has one hell of a speaking voice. It was weird hearing a small Chinese woman with big glasses speak like Charlton Heston coming down from Mount Zion, but that's what she sounds like. She talked at length about beat cops and the work they're doing trying to integrate with the DA, the public housing authority, and the judges. Someone asked her when she was going to tell Gavin that she supported more foot cops in the Lower Haight. "I already did," she said.
After her, Julia Potter from the Mayor's office spoke for a bit-- she'd only heard about the meeting a few hours before, but wanted to come by and throw in what they're up to. I zoned out a bit here, but perked up when she drew crowd ire by mentioning that she and her staff had taken a trip to New York to look at how they'd done community policing and reduced crime. Apparently all of the copies of The Tipping Point were out of the library, so they needed to fly to Manhattan to learn what every criminologist in the country has been studying for fifteen years. Good financial planning there, Gavin!
Various people from the community then talked about various programs and work that us locals can do to help. My favorites were Reverend Trammell, who is organizing a peace march, and Sandra Bolton of the Community Response Network, who is organizing outreach days at the Hayes Valley projects from February 13-Feb. 17 (I'll be at one of them). She's a charismatic woman, and made the very good point that if you don't have a resume, it's hard to get a job, and if the community rooms where you're supposed to go to learn how to write a resume are always locked and the computers are running Windows Me, you're probably going to get up to no good. Amen to that.
The other fun fact I learned is that John Muir Elementary has a PTA now...for the first time in fifty years. And that's the only PTA at any school in the Western Addition. And you don't actually have to have a child in school to be on the PTA. Man, this city is screwed up. They're in desperate need of volunteers, by the way, so if you can help out, please do so. Some other people talked about other projects, and someone managed to work in a totally out-of-place reference to the Iraq war, but by and large most of the suggestions seemed pretty worthy. That said, let's move on to the main event:
Ross Mirkarimi! He's got a really deep voice and a pretty good tan considering how cold it's been. He talked for about twenty minutes and made the following promises:
1) There will be a security camera at Haight and Webster, despite the city having already spent all of the money allocated for cameras. He swore up and down to find the funding to make it happen.
2) If the housing authority can't get it together and start enforcing its own regulations within one year of today (that's January 30, 2008 for those who are going to keep track) he's going to introduce legislation to have the city take over all of the public housing. This will help with security and administration, because apparently
the city cops have some trouble with jurisdiction because the projects are on federal land. Man, that's confusing; thank God I didn't go to law school.
3) Someone asked him if there could be additional criminal penalties for dealing drugs near a medical marijuana provider. He said yes, and that he'd look into making it a city law.
Mirkarimi also threw off the line of the night: "All of the prevention things you guys are talking about are great and necessary, but right now I want a reprieve from the bullets."
After Ross came Bevan Dufty, who dropped the bomb that he's moving to the Lower Haight in a couple of weeks, with his partner and 4 month old child. Bevan Dufty has a child? Who knew? Where was the SFist gossip section on this hot piece of gossip? He also mentioned that cop cars with laptops have no connection to the Internet, so it's impossible to track down criminals by looking at their MySpace pages.(OK, I made the MySpace part up, but it is kind of appalling that the cop laptops aren't networked. I distinctly saw Rev. Trammell say "Jesus" when Dufty dropped that little tidbit).
The meeting ended with a prayer from Trammell, who has a wonderful, mellow presense. The meeting...well, we'll see what gets done. It was nice to see Fong and Mirkarimi make some concrete promises, and I hope that those promises make a difference.
If you're a Lower Haighter and you're interested in helping out in the neighborhood, please sign up for the mailing list at lowerhaight.org. All of the people who are trying to improve the community are on that list, and despite all of my snark here, I do think that we can make a difference and help to calm things down around here.



Bevan Dufty is moving? Um, didn't he just win election to represent Noe Valley and the Mission? Would have been good info to have before voting, no?
-
Our 17-month-old had the right idea when she crapped her diaper at the beginning of the speeches.
The comment in your story, that there is a jurisdiction issue between sf police and the feds, makes perfect sense to me now. I have often wondered about the housing projects a few blocks down from me and now something is a little clearer.
I have a great ‘projects’ story that happened a few years back that I’d like to share publicly now.
I had a job downtown that I’d bike to everyday going down Fulton and then at night, after dark, back up Hayes St.
When I first started it seemed relatively safe even though I biked through a scary, scary housing project. But there were not a lot of people around and the few who hung out at the corner store seemed ‘normal enough’.
Then one day a group of kids began to walk around in a very aggressive way, looking the neighborhood kids in the eye, looking armed and dangerous, kind of looking like members of a high school football team that had gone really, really bad.
They seemed to now own the corner in a creepy, low-key way. Then a few nights later ANOTHER group of kids showed up, and they were staring down the other group of baddies across the street. They were almost lined up football style, again almost like rival football teams that carried guns.
Amidst all this were a car or two of scary looking observers, who I noticed were of latino origin, and who were being obviously noticeable because they smoked cigarettes and held their entire hands out the windows of their cars. They had a very ‘godfather’ air about them, but it could have been my overactive imagination.
All this time I’m wondering, “Where are the cops. Something is about to seriously go down on this street corner.” I guess I thought that this was just police no-mans land, that the gangsters had somehow either taken over city hall or community groups had driven the cops out in the usual politically correct manner. I guess I thought that the cop hating residents deserved whatever they were going to get. Perhaps in hindsight a racist attitude?
Then something really creepy happened. Grown men, not kids, began to show up. They seemed to be uniformed in black leather jackets, and I realize now while writing that this is very reminiscent of the Panthers, but I don’t think these men were in anyway politically active in that way. They began walking around a lot, almost patrolling, as though the grown men of the neighborhood had formed up into an organized gang, or neighborhood watch of some kind.
It was as though there were no cops, ‘justus’, and grown men had formed up in an almost desperate attempt to protect their neighborhood from an actual criminal invasion.
After that I just looked for a new way home from work. I don’t know what happened next except within about a week there was at least one shooting there, and a little later I think I saw a street lamp memorial to a child which may have been completely unrelated.
Anyway, from what I'm reading now, I think I know which side won.
As a relatively recent transplant to the Lower Haight, and SF in general, I have to say that law enforcement here is, in all honesty, fucking pathetic.
The problems in the lower haight are quite solvable. The problem revolves around a few blocks, literally.
How about some actual law enforcement? That'll be a start.
This is where SFist's gossip section was on Bevan's kid:
http://www.sfist.com/archives/2006/04/07/bevan_duftys_babymaking.php
http://www.sfist.com/archives/2006/10/11/make_sure_you_love_the_way_pete_wants_you_to_love.php
al, that was the Death Valley Posse. They often feud with the gang on Fulton one block away. Whenever they feel that the other gang is attacking them or trying to intimidate them, the older members show up on the corner as a form of deterrence.
OOHhhhhh.....
Gosh what happened to Page St. Mob??
OOooohhhh......
Gosh whatever happened to Page St. Mob??
Do a web search for "Page Street Mob" and you'll find out.
Cameras do not hear-- and neither do patrol cars with their windows rolled up.
One of the chief lessons of The Tipping Point was the necessity to go after small infractions to prevent larger crimes.
Cops and politicians should do something positive by finding a way to limit vehicles (boom cars and unmuffled motorcycles) that "tag" neighborhoods with their nauseous sound.
My observations are that they are hands-off as targets of enforcement. Why is this?
Would the Late Night Coalition and political contributions from clubs be a factor?
Some keen journalists need to investigate.
New technologies have made noise more powerful and painful-- and certainly make driving more dangerous. The main message these drivers send is "I can hurt you-- and you can do nothing about it!"
(A message celebrated by advertisers who wish to translate it as "if I can buy it I can have it!")
Cops need to be on the beat-- but they also need to have the tools to enforce quality of life crimes. They need to know by the law what is judicious and what is the difference between harmless and harmful.
"Would the Late Night Coalition and political contributions from clubs be a factor?
Some keen journalists need to investigate."
Wow, that's so far off the mark I don't know where to begin. The SFLNC and local clubs have *nothing* to do with glass-rattling kickers in cars, or the lack of enforcement for whatever it is that they might be doing that is considered uncivil. Unfortunately, SF has no law I know of that regulates noise in this matter, but I *do* know that they have some very strict regulations when it comes to noise coming from clubs. Kinda funny, don't you think, if the SFLNC and clubs would be paying off cops to look the other way when it comes to noisy vehicles, only to have clubs and bars getting shut down for the same reason? What could their motivation possibly be for that?
My boyfriend is a DJ who plays regularly at Underground SF, across the street from where the shootings took place. What would help with a lot of the stuff going on there would simply be some beat cops walking the street. The only problem I've seen is at Haight an Webster - lock down that corner and you'd solve a lot of these problems.
OMFG!!!!!
"...An alleged gang leader has been indicted in the 2002 slaying of a federal witness and two other San Francisco killings committed as part of a drug racketeering conspiracy, authorities said Thursday.
Dennis Cyrus Jr., 20, and six other alleged members of the Western Addition-based Page Street Mob orchestrated a decadelong conspiracy to traffic crack cocaine, according to the indictment unsealed Thursday.
...
...Jimmerson was a member of the Bayview district gang Big Block. He had been freed from custody the month before he died so he could testify against other members of the group in a federal gang case, under a sealed plea deal with the U.S. attorney in San Francisco.
Although the deal was secret, it soon became known that Jimmerson had agreed to testify against the nearly two dozen indicted members of the gang. The Page Street gang was aligned with Big Block, authorities said.
..."
from sfgate
(please hurry and fix the url bug thx)
Jimmerson was a member of the Bayview district gang Big Block. He had been freed from custody the month before he died so he could testify against other members of the group in a federal gang case, under a sealed plea deal with the U.S. attorney in San Francisco.
Although the deal was secret, it soon became known that Jimmerson had agreed to testify against the nearly two dozen indicted members of the gang. The Page Street gang was aligned with Big Block, authorities said.
To Phil--
Those are good points, maybe I was off mark.
I must admit that I do not fully understand who the SFLNC are, why they were formed, what they do, who funds them, or who they represent.
I am not well informed here, but remain skeptical that the rosy picture they paint on their website tells the full story.
I also do not understand why my neighborhood is becoming increasingly rowdy on weekend nights.
I have noticed that most problems happen in the vicinity of clubs rather than from the clubs themselves. If the SFLNC has been instrumental into making clubs better neighbors then my hat's off to them.
I completely agree with you that police should be walking beats for the sake of preventing trouble before it happens.
Hopefully more people will one day realize that mitigating unmuffled motorcycles and boom cars in the city is just as logical.
The noise is torture.
Good comments, all (with the exception of the boom car guy). On the beat cop thing - there are now ten beat cops assigned to North Station. When I moved here three years ago, there were none. They cover Hayes Valley, Lower Haight, and the Divis corridor. They're good guys, and do the best job they can.
But, they're strictly preventitive, and can't be everywhere at once. When the double murder went down two weeks ago, there were two cops on the corner of Haight and Steiner, two blocks away. By the time they got there, the perps were gone. The cops can't be everywhere at once, and saying that they can solve everything by hanging out on that corner is specious. If they're there all the time, something will go down on Buchanan and Page. That's the nature of the beast.
I think Zach's comments are right on target. It is clear where the trouble spots are so why not have police patrol, on foot, the area?
True, the big problems are on the 400 block, but the violence is spreading. There are lots of kids over near the dog park who run drugs and stick-up and rob neighbors. There needs to be a serious crackdown across the whole neighborhood, but starting with the 400 block and the mis-managed projects.
I'm not fond of the projects on Hayes either. Someone from there totalled my parked car with a drunken hit'n run on Page street a few years back. Thankfully, no pedestrians were hurt. He left his brand-new smashed car in the middle of the street as evidence (along with empty beer cans). Witnesses say he was drunk. no conviction. How does someone in the projects have money to buy and smash up a new car? Dealers need to be evicted from public housing.
I went to a meeting on 3.1.07 at the Jewish High School, 1325 Ellis, built like a fortress next to the housing projects. I was curious both to see this new school, a low-key place rarely in the news, and to hear the SFPD police explain how they are dealing with the Western Addition crime.
Small attendance, mostly nonblacks, with a passive crowd, even bored, it seemed. Endless chat and interruptions about "doing more for youth" in the projects... and we are not talking about whipping their backsides and forcing them into workcamps, either - no, more sports, more everything, free from the taxpayers, while they continue to terrify the area, deal drugs, tag buildings with gang graffiti, break into cars, kill each other (well, that's okay, actually, cuts down on the sheer bulk of them...)
Cops insisted that all their efforts are in vain, because the elected judges of SF City and County are too liberal to convict these criminals. They're released on parole, and if juveniles, then there's no penalty. They know full well that they can do what they please, with no consequences, whereas in other parts of the USA, or even California, they'd be in prison for years. They live on the federal dime in the housing projects, and they love every free minute of their time. They never fink on each other, so there's no witnesses to any crime. They claim "black pride" and want "reeespect."
Yeah, right! Scum bums demand this from us!!!??? One day they'll all be lynched and shipped you-know-where when sheer outrage hits SF. A couple of these judges need to be mugged, raped and knifed in the housing projects, or better yet, be forced to live there as a condition of the job, the better to understand the consequences of their lax policies. Let them and their families suffer as we do....
That'll be the day.
To Mark. March 3, 2007 7:15 PM
from the "Boom Car Guy":
What century did you come from to be in favor of lynching and people killing each other to reduce crime?
I think people such as you imagine yourselves to be like a fictional vigilante character played by Charles Bronson when you advocate taking law into your own violent hands. Instead you become a real-life thug that promotes hatred and makes society more dangerous.