About SFist

SFist is a website about San Francisco.

Editor: Brock Keeling
Publisher: Gothamist

About | Advertising | Archive | Contact | Job Board | Mobile | RSS | Staff

Categories
Favorites
Contribute

Latest tip:

RIP, American Musical Theatre of San Jose... <a href="http://www.mercurynews.com/columns/ [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Recent Comments
Blogroll
Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from SFist.

May 3, 2006

SFist Rants: We Want Our 7th Inning Back

baseballflag.jpgOne of our favorite things about baseball is the 7th Inning Stretch. There's something about a stadium full of people standing up and singing a completely quaint, nearly 100 year-old-song in our jaded, post-post punk, post-post modern, post-post-ironic age that gives us the warm fuzzies. But at last Sunday's Giants game, the Giants continued on with a new tradition that is slowly and quickly ruining the 7th Inning Stretch-- the playing of "God Bless America" right before "Take Me Out to the Ballgame."

And yes, we do hate America, why do you ask?

The main reason we don't like it? Hello, overkill. Seriously, we already play the National Anthem. Do we really need to hear two patriotic songs? What's next, playing John Ashcroft's Greatest Hits between innings? "God Bless the USA" every time a home run is hit? We really hate throwing down Godwin, but the playing of the song is a tad Nuremburg-ish. We also hasten to add that it's a little oft putting because the sport is more and more played by people with surnames like Ramirez, Martinez, and Suzuki. Wasn't that the point of the whole WBC?

Then there's the aesthetics of it, what it does to the viewing of the game. What is the mythology of baseball? That it moves to it's own pace, that it doesn't force anyone to do anything until they want to. Pitchers don't have to pitch the ball until they're good and ready, batters don't have to stand in the box until they're good and ready, and fans attending don't have to yell "Charge!" until they're good and ready. It's all about the leisure of it, the laid-back ness of it. Now suddenly, out of nowhere, we have to stand up, take off our hats, and sing some song most of us don't really feel like singing. And yes, we realize that we're kind of supposed to stand up for the 7th Inning Stretch and sing, but you don't really have to. If you don't stand, you don't get some grizzled old baseball vet telling you to stand up because Babe Ruth died so we could have the freedom to sing "Take Me Out to the Ballgame."

Let's look at Sunday's game, the game where we heard the song. It was an absolutely beautiful day to be at the ballpark, in the low-80's with not a cloud in the sky. The ballpark was nearly sold out, there were boats in the Cove, and women in tank tops. Then, out of nowhere, comes the patriotic sing-a-long and we're suddenly transported from "it's 6-0 D'Backs and should we get more garlic fries?" to all the messiness in the world and the war and our President and the fact that because we don't like hearing the song, it makes us nothing but a bunch of hippie, gay-loving, commie pinko, terrorist lovers who make little baby Jesus cry.

And then, after that, out comes the goofy song and that slice of All-American corn pone. Talk about weird transitions. And the song, which should feel as leisurely as the game, comes off as rushed and tacked on. That's just un-baseball. It's even worse in Baltimore where they have to do "God Bless...” then "Take Me Out..." and end it with the O's tradition of John Denver's "Thank God I'm a Country Boy" (another baseball tradition that totally rocks and is worth going to Camden Yards just to see).

We wonder too about the reasoning behind it all. Before the song, there's an announcement over the PA something along the lines that we should "join with Major League Baseball" in singing the song. Does this mean that it's not the Giants behind it, but some edict from Bud himself? It makes sense in a way because Giants' management is savvy enough to know that San Francisco isn't exactly the kind of place that is into the Patriotic frou-frou stuff. So, if it were Bud, then, why would he be requesting it? It couldn't have anything to do with the fact that ever since he took over, the sport has lurched from one PR nightmare to another PR nightmare, could it? Why nobody is cynical enough to use the flag in an attempt to earn good PR points. That would be wrong.

Look, after 9/11, singing "God Bless America" did have certain poignancy to it. Even cynical, cranky ole us got the goose bumps when it was sung in Yankee Stadium in the 2001 series. But now, five years afterwards? Playing "God Bless America" is SO 2001. And yes, we're at war and one could argue that in doing so, we're "honoring the troops" but we think we'd all agree that the best way to honor them is to figure out a way to get them the hell out of there.

Then again, maybe it's just because being from Philadelphia and cutting our sports teeth with the Broad Street Bullies, whenever we hear "God Bless America," we always want to start cheering "Let's Go Fly-ers! Let's Go!" and beat people up. Again, not really a baseball moment.


Email This Entry







Advertisement: SFist Continues Below!

Comments (6)

Hear, hear! We already PROVED how much we love the country at the beginning of the game by singing the National Anthem. And it's not like "Take Take Me Out to the Ballgame" isn't as American as apple pie, or say, "Take Me Out to the Ballgame." Enough with the forced patriotism.

 

I was at ATT park yesterday and no Godblessamerica was played during the 7th inning stretch. Only Takemeouttotheballgame... one verse. Maybe it's a MLB sunday thing?

 

Hear, hear indeed! Baseball is supposed to be a game, a distraction, a few hours in a well-lit paradise where I don't have to think about politics, patriotism, religion, and division. I'm busy hating the visiting team, not the president, and frankly I like it that way. Forcing me into it makes me cranky and ruins some of the magic of situation. Plus, by the seventh inning, my hat hair is usually pretty fierce, so it's better for everybody if the cap stays on.

 

well, I don't commonly leave messages on blogs that are negative, particularly when I don't know someone... However, I must completely disagree with you. I do have quite the bias. I think America, in general, is trying to extract God from everything and write it off as though this were Animal Farm. But God is at the foundation of this country. People built up this country based on values from the Hebrew and Christian scriptures, and I'm glad that it is reflected in America's pastime.

And you may defy the crowd, you may choose to sit instead of stand, that is the beauty of the freedom we have in this country. But I'd rather see baseball players get double the wages they are today than a removal of a song asking God to bless America. We need someone to speak that over this country - might as well be people with passion.

 

I don't care if people ask God to bless America. I just don't think they should flaunt it in public.

 

Here! Here! But only because

1. It happens at EVERY Sunday game

2. It REPLACES "Take Me Out to the Ballgame" in that song's 100th anniversary (in 2008).

3. "America the Beautiful" has a more pleasant melody.

4. It's been 5 years (in 2008) since the war began, and 7 (in Sept. 2008) since the planes slammed into the World Trade Center & Pentagon.

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.