American Football Spectacular: Wild Card Wknd 2006, 'You're In The Saddle Now'

pl_180601.jpg

Every Head Coach has inclinations about how they like to run their team. For example, our Niners' savior-genius Bill Walsh ran a short passing game informed by strong running. Bill Cowher, Head Coach of the Steelers, prefers heavy ball-control pounding with a dash of trick plays, and a powerful 3-4 defense. The two Head Coaches in The Battle Of The Repurposed are both out of their comfort zone, and that is fascinating.

Tampa Bay's hella young Head Coach JonGruden (late of our Oakland Raiders) prefers to run a complex offense with veteran players he can count on, while his Defensive Coordinator Monte Kiffin runs their voracious Cover 2 zone defensive scheme. This year he's had to rely on the bleach-haired third-year Chris Simms, son of Phil, at QB. Gruden simplified his offensive game and TB succeeded. His 2005 first round draft pick RB Carnell "Cadillac" Williams was awarded Offensive Rookie Of The Year. The Bucs are amongst the simplest teams in the league right now --they'll beat you on execution, not so much on strateejury.

Washington's Hall Of Fame Head Coach Joe Gibbs loves ball-control. Loves it. In his first tenure with Washington, he was known for bruising line-play from his "Hogs" opening up holes for big grinder-style running backs. When it came to passing, Gibbs would look to wily possession receivers like Art Monk, a master of the curl route. Now, having returned to the WAS sideline at the behest of meddling owner Dan Snyder, Gibbs has been forced to go light due to inherited personnel, and a fragmented front office (it's Snyder's fault).

Washington currently has a light, speedy back in Clinton Portis, and their best receiving weapon this year is travel-sized WR burner Santana Moss. Moss is a long-ball threat, but not a guy who you'd want to go over the middle versus a linebacker.

These teams met up in the regular season, trading blows back-and-forth with Tampa coming out on top by one point 36-35 after Gruden called for a dramatic 2-point conversion with under a minute to go.

Applicable Metaphor: The television show Iron Chef. Neither of these Head Coaches prefers what ingredients they have to work with, yet both were able to adapt through ups-and-downs to get into the playoffs. Who will be the victor? Whose offensive scheme reigns
supreme?

By SFist Christopher Rogers, contributing

Jacksonville vs. New England
Saturday, January 7, 2006
The Battle Of The Arcs

Momentum. In American football, it's an ineffable thing. It can't be quantified in advance, it can't be measured or summed, it can only be spoken of with certainty after the fact. And momentum is everything when it comes to the Battle Of The Arcs between Jacksonville and the defending champion New England Patriots.

The Pats had a hard early part of the season, losing a bunch of players to injury. With all the running backs of consequence injured, San Mateo's Tom Brady hauled the team on his back and willed them through the middle portion of the season. Now the Pats, as is their way, are getting healthy and peaking at the right time. They won four of their last five, dropping their last game against Miami by resting their starters, and 'cause Miami's Head Coach Nick Saban wanted it more. But here comes New England down the stretch into the playoffs again, and even with a patchwork secondary ranked 31st in pass defense, nobody wants to play them.

The Jags on the other hand, have had a weak weak weak schedule since Week 09 (HOU, BAL, TEN, ARZ, CLE, IND being the one exception, SF, HOU again, TEN again), so it's almost impossible to know how they'll react to a competitive matchup. The Jags are an anomalous team to begin with. Hewn in the hard-nosed image of their Head Coach Jack Del Rio, a former linebacker, Jacksonville fights hard, but they don't always fight smart. Their reputation is that of playing to their opponent's level -- winning games they shouldn't win, and losing games they shouldn't lose.

Now, besides attempting to regain inertia, JAX also regains starting QB Byron Leftwich from a broken leg. So how will they respond in Foxborough after so long without useful games? Can they correct their downward arc? There is no surety, but from the outset, it doesn't look good for the Jaguars.

Applicable Metaphor: Mike Jones' quotation "You don't work, you don't eat. You don't grind, you don't shine." What Mr. Jones (famously reachable at 281 330-8004) meant is that accomplishment is directly tied to hard work. This is true. How it applies to this matchup is that though both teams are hurting in their secondaries, this cold weather game will be won on the ground. How healthy is the Jag's Fred Taylor really? Can the mangled Pats O-line stand its ground against the fearsome Jacksonville defensive line? We'll see who shines.

Carolina vs. The New York Giants
Sunday, January 8, 2006
The Battle Of The Streaky

Who what? This is a game that can only be predicted in saying that it cannot be predicted. Here's why: no one yet knows which teams will show up to play.

Seemed like throughout the middle of the season, sports journalists were falling all over themselves to write stories about "this week is the week that Carolina takes control of the NFC." Then the Panthers dropped games to Chicago, Tampa Bay, and Dallas. Carolina's Head Coach John Fox has labored mightily through yet another odd season for the Panthers: he lost Kris Jenkins, one of the league's best defensive lineman, for the year with an injured knee. He has seen WR Steve Smith emerge as one of the most explosive playmakers in the NFL this year, even with opponents' defenses concentrating on him. He's seen the decline of RB Stephen Davis, who classily stepped aside for his understudy DeShaun Foster. Just another wild Panthers season. So who's gonna show up? The team that smashed the Patriots and twice blew out the Falcons, or the team that fell apart in Chicago, and lost out by the barest of margins against the Cowboys?

On the other side of the equation, the New York (American football) Giants have also survived a tumultuous season that saw the twin emergences of Eli Manning at QB & Osi Umenyiora (pronounced OH-see YOU-man-you-a) at DE opposite perennial Michael Strahan, the death of owner Wellington Mara, and a grip of career games from Tiki Barber. A discounted team entering the season, the Giants flashed surprising offensive firepower from Manning The Younger and Tiki, but couldn't put away the Seahawks in a close game due to kicking problems, and dropped a late-season game to a desperate Washington team.

Now, with a bunch of LBs injured, can this mixed-bag of a team get past the NFL's ultimate streaky franchise?

Both teams will try to whack about the other's QB as much as possible. Both sets of defensive ends are amongst the cream of the NFL. Tellingly, Fox was the DL Coach for the Giants during their last Super Bowl run.

Applicable Metaphor: Eminem. As AFS' Uncle Steve said regarding Em, "When he's on, he's really on, but when he's not..." Then he laughed to complete his point. And so go both these franchises. When they're "on" they can compete with the best the NFC has to offer. The question then becomes will they be on or no?
pl_193176.jpg

Pittsburgh at Cincinnati
Sunday, January 8, 2006
The Battle For The AFC North

The Bengals hadn't won their division since 1990, but this year they have. Surging under Head Coach Marvin Lewis, Cincinnati won a whole bunch with an grind-and-shoot offense, and a opportunistic defense. CIN
had the best turnover difference in the league at +24 and enters the playoffs in a position they're not used to...well, being in the playoffs.

Pittsburgh is accustomed to wearing the crown, having won the AFC North in 2004, 2002 (post NFL realignment), and 2001. Hugely-jawed Steelers' Head Coach Bill Cowher has kept his franchise competitive for a long time with his uniquely Pittsburgh style of play (see first paragraph above). PIT lost a bunch of games this season that they shouldn't have. QB wunderkind Ben Roethlisberger was out for a bit, and the Steelers had to shuffle their running backs. Splitting their season series with Baltimore, and losing to Jacksonville on a Tommy Maddox miscue both arguably shouldn't have happened.

The Steelers were forced to run the table to get into the postseason past Kansas City and San Diego. They've basically been playing playoff football since the December 4 loss to the Bengals.

Now the rematch of the upstarts against the hungry former division champs is set. Both teams finished 11 and 5, but CIN had the tiebreaker. Cincinnati are underdogs on their own field despite having won the Week 13 game.

Just as there's nothing more pathetic than an emo song gone awry, there's few things more pathetic than a ball-control team that can't keep the ball. Cincy is gonna try to put points on the board quick to make PIT play from behind. In a cold Paul Brown Stadium, we will see which defense acquiesces first, and which team can claim to be the best in the AFC North this
season.

There's gonna be quarterbacks wearing gloves on their throwing hands in this one. Bless you, o cold weather football, bless you.

Applicable Metaphor: The song "Afghamistam / Micaragua" by the band Botch from its EP "An Anthology Of Dead Ends."
One long song stretched across the last two tracks of their final EP; it's about driving over the pass to Tahoma, and ostensibly regarding the fact of the track being the band's last song. There is a moment in the song where after a lull, the track breaks open like a herd of Clydesdales bursting from a snow-swept barn in slow motion. "RIIIDE!" bellows singer David Verellen as the song thunders downslope. This sort of inertia is what one can expect from the running game on both sides of the ball in the PIT vs CIN matchup; two of the league's best "big backs" in Jerome Bettis and Rudi Johnson churning out yards on the ground. Look for plenty of well-intentioned tackles to get broken off like politicians' promises. That's entertainment. That's American football.

Next time on your American Football Spectacular: Summations from your Bay Area college and NFL teams, more playoff fodder, and glee.

Email This Entry


Comments (2) [rss]

Wonderful analysis, Jon.

I can't imagine a more evenly-matched game than Washington-TB. Brunell vs. Chris Simms, both of whom got stronger as the season progressed. I think Washington wins on D.

Pats are smoking hot and have home field. On a neutral field, I'd have to take the Jags' Smith & Jones against the Pats banged-up corner coverage, but in the January cold against a team from Florida -- I mean, this is what the Patriots *do*! Plus, Belichick went to Wesleyan, while Jack Del Rio is a meathead.

Carolina beats NY Giants on QB experience advantage. I think Eli actually regressed as the season went on. Meanwhile, if the Panthers are streaky AND they beat the Falcons by 183 points last week...

The Steelers with a healthy Rothlisberger are the most complete team in the league. Cincy doesn't have a chance. Plus, no team with uniforms as shitty as the Bengals' can advance too deep into January.

I'd love to take credit for the analysis, but it's all Chris R.


For what it's worth too, I totally agree with your analysis of the Bengals. But if that rule were true, it would have disqualified the Broncos and will doom the Seahawks this year.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About SFist

SFist is a website about San Francisco.

Editor: Brock Keeling
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

New Years Eve is coming up quick. Check out SFNewYEars.com for information on all the parties in SF.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from SFist.

All Our RSS